MeCard vs vCard: 어떤 연락처 형식을 선택할까
Comparing MeCard and vCard QR code formats: data size, field support, device compatibility, and recommendations.
MeCard vs vCard: Which Contact Format to Choose
Both MeCard and vCard formats encode contact information for QR codes, but they differ in size, compatibility, and field support. Choosing the right format affects the QR code's physical size and scannability.
MeCard Format
Developed by NTT DoCoMo (Japan), MeCard uses a compact syntax:
MECARD:N:Doe,John;TEL:+15550123;EMAIL:[email protected];URL:https://example.com;;
vCard Format
The international standard (RFC 6350) uses a more verbose structure:
BEGIN:VCARD
VERSION:3.0
N:Doe;John;;;
FN:John Doe
TEL:+15550123
EMAIL:[email protected]
URL:https://example.com
END:VCARD
Size Comparison
For identical contact data, MeCard is approximately 30-40% smaller than vCard:
| Contact Data | MeCard Size | vCard Size |
|---|---|---|
| Name + phone | ~40 bytes | ~85 bytes |
| Name + phone + email | ~70 bytes | ~120 bytes |
| Full contact (5 fields) | ~120 bytes | ~200 bytes |
This size difference translates directly to a smaller QR code version, which means fewer modules and easier scanning at smaller physical sizes.
Field Support
| Field | MeCard | vCard |
|---|---|---|
| Name | Yes | Yes |
| Phone | Yes | Yes (multiple, typed) |
| Yes | Yes (multiple, typed) | |
| URL | Yes | Yes |
| Address | Yes | Yes (structured) |
| Organisation | Yes (ORG:) |
Yes |
| Title/Role | No | Yes |
| Birthday | Yes (BDAY:) |
Yes |
| Photo | No | Yes (base64) |
| Notes | Yes (NOTE:) |
Yes |
| Social profiles | No | Yes (v4.0) |
Compatibility
| Platform | MeCard | vCard |
|---|---|---|
| iOS | Good (via camera) | Excellent |
| Android | Excellent | Excellent |
| Windows Phone | Limited | Good |
Both formats work well on modern iOS and Android. vCard has a slight edge on iOS for field recognition, while MeCard has historically had stronger Android support.
Recommendation
| Scenario | Recommended Format |
|---|---|
| Basic contact (name, phone, email) | MeCard — smaller QR code |
| Full business card with title and org | vCard — more fields |
| Small print size (business card) | MeCard — fewer modules |
| International enterprise use | vCard — ISO standard |
Key Takeaways
- MeCard is 30-40% smaller than vCard for identical data
- vCard supports more fields (title, photo, social profiles)
- Both work well on modern iOS and Android devices
- Use MeCard for compact QR codes with basic contact info
- Use vCard when you need the full range of contact fields